
While vacationing at a beach house in Sea Ranch (Sonoma/Mendocino, CA coast) this week, I had the pleasure of making Pollo al Diablo (Chicken Diablo) while looking out at the ocean and watching foxes and deer prance through the meadow. Not your everyday cooking experience. The wise person who designed this house must have enjoyed cooking and eating, because the kitchen has the best window view of the beach, and the deck, which is the perfect spot for a barbecue and patio table, also faces the ocean.
Before I get started about the sauce, let's talk about chicken. I have not always been able to cook chicken. When I was a preteen and my mom was teaching me how to cook, I couldn't stand handling raw chicken. I remember refusing to touch it. She didn't force me, but she said, "Someday, you'll have your own family, and you'll cook chicken." Yes, Mom, you were right. At the start of my domestic family life, I was able to put off this inevitability for a few years by being a vegetarian. Around 2000 I started eating meat again, and it took me quite awhile to cook it on my own (rather than ordering it at a restaurant). I started with fish, then beef, then chicken was last.
I still do not enjoy handling raw chicken! And I'm just talking about boneless, skinless chicken breasts that you only have to trim and cut. Yes, I am THAT wimpy. I'm not even talking about handling whole chickens, where you sometimes have to cut away bit of liver and kidney and such. Sorry, but I'm just not there yet. I might get there, as I work my way through this cookbook and become more and more adventurous.
In spite of my squeamishness, with the right chicken recipe, the results are well worth it. Delayed gratification. It's not like recipes that are a pleasure to prepare all the way through, like gazpacho, or plantain omelet. There is nothing about the sensory experience of handling raw chicken that is enjoyable to me. But Pollo al Diablo is definitely worth it! And it is really very simple to prepare.
You start by making the marinade/sauce at least two hours before cooking. This sauce reminds me of something you would have seen in a cookbook or magazine in the 1970s, with ketchup and sour cream. Use good quality ingredients, and it works. I used Westbrae organic unsweetened ketchup, and Trader Joe's sour cream. Also, Trader Joe's hot sauce, which I like better than those I've tried from Whole Foods.
Mix 1/4 cup to 1/2 cup hot sauce (depending on how spicy you like it), 1/4 cup honey, and 1 cup sour cream in a bowl. The mixture is a pale pink/orange color. Drop 1/2 tsp. each of paprika and cumin on top. Don't mix it yet! Look at how pretty it is. The powdered spices look like an artist's palette. Add 1/2 cup ketchup. Stir it slowly and watch the colors swirl and change. It's like mixing paint, except it smells yummy. Keep mixing until it is all blended and smooth, then marinate 6 chicken breast halves in half of it for at least 2 hours in the refrigerator. Reserve the rest of the sauce in the refrigerator.
You can cook the marinated chicken on the grill, or in a heavy skillet on the stove. Whenever grilling is an option, weather permitting, I grill. And with the beautiful scenery, it was an easy choice. The recipe says to use 1/2 cup vegetable or peanut oil for cooking. I did not need to use nearly that much oil. I used extra virgin olive oil, simply because it's the only oil I had on hand. If I'd been at home, I probably would have used peanut oil for better flavor. The olive oil worked just fine, though. I brushed the grill with a nice coating of olive oil, and grilled the chicken on both sides, occasionally brushing with more sauce as it cooked. Heat the other half of the sauce in a small saucepan on the stove, being careful not to let it boil, and serve alongside the chicken.
Now, a word about hot sauce. The recipe calls for 1/2 cup of hot sauce. I used half of that, thinking that is one hell of a lot of hot sauce, and hoping my kids would try this recipe too. 1/4 cup of hot sauce made it plenty spicy enough for the grownups, and too spicy for the kids. Personally I could have handled it a little bit spicier, but not much. You can always add extra hot sauce at the table.
I served this with grilled zucchini, rainbow shell pasta with olive oil and Romano cheese, and romaine salad with cucumbers and apples. For the zucchini, I sliced it lengthwise into long slabs, brushed it with a dressing (olive oil, white wine vinegar, salt, pepper, and garlic powder), and grilled it over low/medium heat on both sides. Zucchini prepared in this way is mild yet flavorful, and a perfect accompaniment to the spicy chicken. Chilled Rosé alongside is cooling and refreshing.
One final note: leftovers of this chicken, the next day, cold from the fridge, are awesome. There is nothing like leftover cold chicken, if it's good. And if it's good hot, it's even better cold, the next day. It's good straight, but would be nice in a sandwich too.
Enjoy!
~Lori